Friday, April 30, 2010

Structure for Creative Expression Practice


This is the second (of eight) posts in a series I announced here, in which I'll explore the question of how to create structures to support that part of spiritual practice called "Creative Expression" or, as Daido Roshi called it, "Art Practice." These posts are not meant to be the definitive word; rather, they are more of a travelogue documenting my journey into my new home in the mountains.

So, for me, creative expression is primarily through music, painting, and writing, listed here in descending order of passion. There are few things I would rather do than pick up an electric guitar, crank up the amplifier, and play along either with good friends or a blasting stereo. I have been playing guitar since I was 19, and while I'm not particularly skilled, there are things about myself that I can express only through that medium. I picked up painting much later in life, at age 40. I am much less skilled as a painter than as a guitarist, and have yet to reach the point of expressing personal truths as deep as those I can express on guitar. Nonetheless, I take a great deal of satisfaction about this part of my practice. Finally, sometimes, but not often, writing is an expression of my creative spirit. I am still very young in recognizing this aspect of my creative life, and therefore much less secure and disciplined about it.

Here are my thoughts about building a structure for this part of my practice.
  • Place. Much of the moving-in process for me this past month has been about creating physical spaces for creative expression. Reflecting my own priorities, most of that effort (not to mention financial investment) went to creating a space for music. That space is a dominant feature of my living space, and rightfully so. It is hard to forget about this dimension of my practice with such a reminder on center stage in my living room. Finding space for painting is, given the physical constraints of my small home, a bit more difficult. My middle ground has been to find a permanent, easy-to-get-to place for my art supplies, with the notion that when it's time to paint, it will be relatively easy to set up a canvas either indoors or outside on my front porch. Writing, of course, can happen anywhere. Most of my creative writing is in the form of songs and poems, which I can do anywhere.
  • Time. Music practice can come in several forms, and each of the forms has its own requirements regarding time. When I'm playing music alone, I have virtually no constraints, as my neighbors cannot hear me, even when I play loudly, and there is nobody but my canary to disturb. Typically, solo music practice for me is some combination of scales and arpeggios mixed with jamming sessions with the stereo (usually Eric Clapton). I try to do this in the morning, as the energy generated in this process has a lovely carryover effect for the rest of the day. Playing with others, however, requires planning and initiative. This is truer now in some ways, since my move to rural New York. At least until mid-June, I am blessed with having my neighbor David nearby, and we have already started but I hope to be a tradition of regular sessions. Beyond that, however, I am reaching out to other friends and family members, extending invitations to visit, with the expressed hope that we plan to make music at some point during these visits. As for painting and writing, but I have yet to be as disciplined about those two domains as I am about music. Stay tuned for the unfoldment of that dimension of my practice.
  • Reminders. As is the case for meditation practice, I schedule my music practice at specific times of the day on my Google calendar. It helps to have a little reminder dialog box pop up on my screen to drive me away from my computer and into the studio.
  • Tools. Naturally, my instruments and recording equipment are a key part of this structure. Another dimension, however, was to make sure that the stereo system with which I would be jamming was up to the task, so I did a bit of augmenting of that system when I moved here. Because I want to perform with other musicians, too, it was important to me that I have instruments that I might not necessarily play myself, to further facilitate artistic collaboration. So, I have added a drum kit to my collection of instruments in the hopes of luring drummers (notably, my sons or their friends) into collaboration. Having enough microphones for all the singers and the room is important, as well.
  • Community. As I mentioned above, collaboration in art practice is a powerful way to invite myself into practice. It is not a coincidence that the last time I did anypainting was a collaborative effort with my friend Rick on a large canvas. Again, as with music practice, it will take initiative and planning to make sure that visually artistic friends are invited into collaborative space with me.
As you can tell from this post, creating structures for creative expression is, in my case still a work-in-progress. This is true despite the fact that one of the major reasons underlying my move to this new home was because I felt I had a better opportunity to create just such structures here than elsewhere. Stay tuned for further developments (particularly around painting and writing).

Next up . . . body practice.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Structure for Meditation Practice

As I said I'd do in yesterday's blog post, I'll start my exploration of practice structures with Daido Loori's first gate (of eight) of practice: formal meditation practice. What does structure look like for this?
  • Place. Many of my students over the years have reported that their formal practice did not really get started until they created a dedicated physical space for it. Having dedicated space has always helped me, so one of the first things I did when I move here was create such a space. I use rugs to demark the space as a single-function space, preventing the gradual erosion of the sanctity of the place.
  • Time. Carving out time is another important aspect of structural support. If you're living with people, you may need to come to an agreement with them, or otherwise adapt yourself to their schedules if your living space forces you into close company. If you are living alone or have a large enough shared housing situation that you can get alone at will, you're still not out of the woods. You still may need to navigate a work schedule, a sleep schedule, or even your own energy level. While I live alone, I nevertheless need to keep in mind that (1) my clients start calling about 10 a.m. Eastern, (2) my energy level starts to drop after 6, and (3) most of my occasions to socialize with my neighbors will be after 6. So, as a part of my daily practice of organizing my day, I make three formal appointments for meditation, typically immediately after I'm done with my daily organizing (often around 8:30 a.m.), midday (preferably around noon), and mid-afternoon (preferably around 2:30 p.m.). I treat those appointments as though they were with a client, i.e., difficult to move and virtually uninterruptible.
  • Reminders. Setting aside the time is not worth much if you don't remember that you've set aside the time. So, in addition to putting it on the calendar, I have calendar pop-up reminders to jar me out of my workaday stupor and back to the cushion.
  • Tools. While tools certainly aren't necessary for seated meditation, they can be helpful. My minimum preferred tool kit involves: (1) seating (I use a Mountain Seat zafu and zabuton combination), (2) a timer (I use a mindfulness bell on the internet), (3) candles, (4) flowers, (5) incense, and (6) incense holder. I also keep various sacred texts at hand from diverse traditions in case my meditation practice also involves reading or chanting. My current list includes my Revised Standard Edition of The Holy Bible, the Bhagavad-Gita, and a manual of Zen chants. I also have at least one bell at hand. My current space has a crystal singing bowl.
  • Altar items. In addition to the tools of meditation, I populate my meditation space with various items that have meaning for me -- a rock given to me by a student, statues (in my case, a large Buddha-head and several tiny Shinto figures) and other miscellany, all designed to support my notion that this is an important part of my day.
  • Intellectual underpinnings. Part of my supporting structure is my belief that this is an essential part of my daily practice. So, I go out of my way to find readings that support that notion, from the secular (research showing the clinical benefits of meditation) to the sacred (texts from all traditions).
  • Community. There is a reason every major religious tradition stresses community -- it can support our development in powerful ways, one of which is to provide more impetus for formal practice. Historically, I've had the luxury of a weekly practice group in which I was a member and one or two teaching sessions, all of which served as meditation communities. Several years ago, I even participated in a small group of meditators who were separated by hundreds of miles but met each morning via webcam to sit together. When I spent a month here at Shalom Mountain (across the street from my new home) over 3 years ago, a group of us met with some regularity at 7:30 in the morning for yoga and meditation. I'm still feeling my way into the current mountain-top community, and will be looking for signs of such a community, either already in existence or ready to emerge. And, I do have my webcams . . .
OK, that's a good start. If you have any other ideas about what structures support a formal meditation practice, please let me know by adding a comment to this post.

Next up . . . Creative Expression!

Monday, April 19, 2010

Supportive Structures for Mindfulness Practice

As I'm settling into my new home in the mountains of New York, I'm struck by how much effort is involved in creating a supportive context for my practice. There's nothing like uprooting yourself from your life and starting completely over to bring into focus the structures needed to support a practice.

But before you can examine the structures needed to support practice, you'd better get clear about what you mean by "practice". Too often, it seems to me, the definition of "practice" is too narrow, even unidimensional, focusing like a laser on seated meditation. Like a table with one or two legs, such a practice cannot stand for long.

I find useful the work of the late Daido Loori, the former abbot of Zen Mountain Monastery, where I received most of my Zen training. His seminal book, The Eight Gates of Zen, outlines a broad definition of practice that, in my view, is appropriately sweeping, and applicable not only to practice in the Zen tradition but also in about any tradition I can imagine. If you mean to transform your life, you're going to need to do more -- a whole lot more -- than sit on a cushion.

Here's his list (revised for a broader-than-Zen readership):
  • Formal meditation
  • Study with a teacher
  • Academic study
  • Ritual
  • Moral behavior
  • Creative expression
  • Body practice
  • Work practice
So, over the next few posts (eight, to be precise!), I'll explore what supportive structure means for all these realms, at least for this particular practitioner as I build these structures from the ground up.

Sunday, April 11, 2010

Self Awareness and Self Responsiveness

Much is made of self-awareness. Dogen lifted it up the study of the self as being identical with the study of the Way.

To study the Way is to study the self. To study the self is to forget the self. To forget the self is to be enlightened by all things of the universe. To be enlightened by all things of the universe is to cast off the body and mind of the self as well as those of others. Even the traces of enlightenment are wiped out, and life with traceless enlightenment goes on forever and ever.

It seems, though, that self-awareness is insufficient. We also need a self-responsiveness. Think of the action of driving a car. It is not sufficient to keep our eyes and ears open when we drive; rather, we must also steer and brake the car in response to what we see and hear.

This occurs to me this Sunday morning, my second since moving into solitude in the mountains of New York, because I did a radical thing: at about 10:30 a.m., when I became aware that I was tired, I took a 75 minute nap. I responded to my awareness of my tiredness.

Why is this radical? Because, as I look back over my life, I have almost never done this except when on vacation. And I am not on vacation. In fact, I have quite a long task list today: expense reports to complete, invoices to send to clients, work to do for other clients, and filing an extension for my taxes.

Why is it such a rare thing for me to respond in this way to such a basic need as rest? The easy answer would be "other people." The expectations of others -- in my family, workplace, culture -- make such a late-morning nap odd at the least, perhaps a sign of an ill-spent evening the night before or, even worse, the deadly sin of Sloth.

Perhaps, also, the activities of others prevent this self-responsiveness: the thumping of teenage boys, the lively conversation of loved ones, perhaps even a stereo or TV. So, only in the absence of other people am I free to respond to myself. There is a kind of comfort in knowing that I have been chronically unresponsive to my own needs because of the intervention of other people. The solution in such a scenario is simple -- avoid other people.

Yet, seeing that as the only solution leaves out the possibility of transformation of relationships. Imagine, for a moment, if I decided to communicate to the people with whom I live, work, and recreate that I am the sort of person who responds to my needs:
  • I sleep when I'm tired.
  • I awake when I'm rested.
  • I eat when I'm hungry.
  • I withdraw when I'm feeling the need for solitude.
  • I make music when my own song bubbles up to the surface.
  • I weep when I am sad.
This might involve a radical transformation of some, if not most, relationships. And that would be only the first step. I might also have to negotiate with these people in order to be able to do this in community. We'd have to have a discussion, perhaps, about the conditions I need in order to be able to be self-responsive.

But wait, there's more! This no doubt would get some of the people in my relationships to say things like, "well, what about my needs? I'd like to sleep when I'm tired, too, and I cannot do that when you're singing a Verde aria!" This could erupt into open negotiations among people about how to get our needs met. We might need to ask each other for help in meeting our needs. This might even involve negotiating fundamental changes in how I live, work, and play in community, changes that make it more likely that all of us will get more of our needs met.

Why is this not happening with greater frequency now? One of the reasons, I believe, is because of the stories we tell ourselves and each other about getting our needs met. "It's selfish. It's narcissistic. It's hedonistic." And, in the face of those stories, we tuck our needs away, one at a time, until we're dragging ourselves around, drained, physically and emotionally, resentful, angry, and wondering where the juice of our lives went.

Another is because we are afraid of the "no" we expect to get when we ask for the meeting of our needs. Our fear of "no", in essence, provides us with the "no" without even asking. I get to resent you for your "no" even though you've not given it to me.

So, today I vow to practice both self-awareness and self-responsiveness. Of course, it will be easier when, on days like today, I'm likely to be alone most of the day, kind of like riding a bike with training wheels on an empty cul-de-sac. I'll watch, I'll listen, and I'll respond, taking baby steps.

Once I get good at that, perhaps I'll know better how to start redesigning my relationships so that, not only will I have my needs met, but so will my beloveds, co-workers, and play mates.

Some of you reading this have already fully accomplished this in your lives. I ask you to share (or at least reflect on) your experiences: What worked, what didn't, what obstacles did you encounter along the way?

Others of you, like me, have accomplished this in some domains but not others. You, I ask to share or reflect on the characteristics of these domains. What conditions make it more likely that you can have these kinds of relationships?

Still others seldom, if ever, feel free to act on your own needs. You I invite to survey your domain and ask, "where can I start? Where can I begin to carve out a life that is that free." Remember, it doesn't have to be all at once.

OK, enough of that. I don't feel like writing anymore. I feel like walking in the warm sun and enjoying this glorious spring day.

Bye!