Tuesday, September 22, 2009

Hierarchical Love Maps

My young friend Blair Haggett posted a Facebook inquiry into levels of love, making a valiant effort to organize various types of love into a hierarchical system. Daring to go where few dare to tread, he does an excellent job, including pointing out the limitations and problems with his own system.

Is hierarchy bad? Hell no! Some things are higher (or deeper) than other, love included. Then what's the problem?

Here's how I replied to Blair, and I'm thankful for his thought-provoking catalyst for this riff:

==============

I think one problem is that we have too many meanings for this one word. Because of that, purely tiered systems cannot hold up and contain all the meanings.

Now, if we pick a narrower meaning for love, stick to it, we might be able to tier that meaning, and then, say, come up with another word (e.g., "wahoo"?) for another dimension of love, and then tier that. Example: What if "love" simply describes our circle of compassion? If we limited it to that, then ever-widening circles would constitute our "tiers of love." So, my love for my mom and dad (only) would be subordinate to my love for mom, dad, and sibs, which would be subordinate to the love that included uncles and cousins, and so on until we talk about a much broader (higher?) love for all sentient beings, then love for all beings sentient or insentient, etc.

Then, if we use, say, "wahoo" for that flavor of what we might call love that also involves lust or passion, then we could probably tier that. For example, "I wahoo you if" (you stay good-looking, you're rich, you are well thought of, smart, evolved) is subordinate in our Tiered Wahoo System to "wahoo because" (you're good-looking, rich, smart, evolved, etc.), which is then subordinate to "wahoo in spite of" (all your flaws).

The Greeks did a better job than we by having at least a couple of major words for what we now lump to gether under the love umbrella, but I think the Family of Love has a lot more children than two.

So, let's draw more than one or two hierarchical "love maps"!

===============

Thanks again, Blair. That was fun!

Serenity Prayer, Redux: Rain is Wet: Get Over It

Serenity prayer, first part:

God grant me the serenity
to accept the things I cannot change;
courage to change the things I can;
and wisdom to know the difference.

Oddly enough, this is the core of my recent practice, the one that has pulled me out of my summer doldrums. I say "oddly enough" because it is an overused-to-the-point-of-trite aphorism and as old as the hills.

Yet, in its core, it is radical.

First, Radical Acceptance. What would it be like to accept everything that is unchangeable? Or, even more radical, to embrace it? To embrace it all. To even love it all. I daresay few of us have succeeded in taking this first line of the prayer to its maximum interpretation.

Rephrased:

I choose to love all that is.

And now, the rest of this first part, Radical Responsibility.

To ask, what choices do I have, what can I do now? Not some Secret-inspired narcissistic responsibility for all of creation, but a clear-eyed assessment of what I can do. Very often we obscure this view so as to evade responsibility for our actions and lay it elsewhere. We have far more choices than we typically admit.

A classic trick -- we deny the choices we are making where the consequences of choosing otherwise seem dire. For example, "I cannot quit my job." The truth is, unless you are enslaved, you can always quit your job. Now, the consequences may be serious, but you can always quit your job. "I'm stuck in a terrible relationship." Nobody is stuck in a terrible relationship that they cannot choose out of. We can tell an endless string of these lies to ourselves and others, painting ourselves into a corner of perceived helplessness and victimization.

What is the practice?

Use moments of anger, despair, frustration, as warning signals, and then consciously ask questions like:
  • What can I do, right now?
  • What power do I have?
  • Where in my life do I have the capacity to influence?
Build a day out of these questions.

What about the rest of the problems, the ones beyond my control?

I have used humor to great effect. For example, when I catch myself whining about some idiotic pundit, or the foolishness or even evil of some people, or the brevity of life, I try to come up with a similar complaint about a thing I cannot change, like "rain is so wet! God I hate that rain is wet."

Of course, I could choose to move to the desert . . .

Monday, August 24, 2009

The flaws in our wood

I've been grappling with lingering, general dissatisfaction. While many things and people have, from time to time in recent weeks, been the object of that dissatisfaction, meditation reveals that the core dissatisfaction has been with certain aspects of my self that some inner voices have described as "flaws". Of course, this is not the first, nor will it be the last, time I engage in this kind of self-criticism. This particular bout has been resilient to my normal approaches.

Driving back from South Carolina yesterday, I put on David Whyte's recitation of his poem, The Faces at Braga. Suffice to say, the tears came when he reached the lines:

If only we knew
as the carver knew, how the flaws
in the wood led his searching chisel to the very core,

we would smile, too
and not need faces immobilized
by fear and the weight of things undone.

By the way, I recommend you get "Close to Home", the 1992 CD that has his recitation set to gorgeous music.

Here it is in its entirety. Thank you, David.

The Faces at Braga

In monastery darkness
by the light of one flashlight
the old shrine room waits in silence

While above the door
we see the terrible figure,
fierce eyes demanding, "Will you step through?"

And the old monk leads us,
bent back nudging blackness
prayer beads in the hand that beckons.

We light the butter lamps
and bow, eyes blinking in the
pungent smoke, look up without a word,

see faces in meditation,
a hundred faces carved above,
eye lines wrinkled in the hand held light.

Such love in solid wood!
Taken from the hillsides and carved in silence
they have the vibrant stillness of those who made them.

Engulfed by the past
they have been neglected, but through
smoke and darkness they are like the flowers

we have seen growing
through the dust of eroded slopes,
then slowly opening faces turned toward the mountain.

Carved in devotion
their eyes have softened through age
and their mouths curve through delight of the carvers hand.

If only our own faces
would allow the invisible carver's hand
to bring the deep grain of love to the surface.

If only we knew
as the carver knew, how the flaws
in the wood led his searching chisel to the very core,

we would smile, too
and not need faces immobilized
by fear and the weight of things undone.

When we fight with our failing
we ignore the entrance to the shrine itself
and wrestle with the guardian, fierce figure on the side of good.

And as we fight
our eyes are hooded with grief
and our mouths are dry with pain.

If only we could give ourselves
to the blows of the carver's hands,
the lines in our faces would be the trace lines of rivers

feeding the sea
where voices meet, praising the features
of the mountain and the cloud and the sky.

Our faces would fall away
until we, growing younger toward death
every day, would gather all our flaws in celebration

to merge with them perfectly,
impossibly, wedded to our essence,
full of silence from the carver's hands.


David Whyte, Where Many Rivers Meet

Sunday, May 31, 2009

Hope: All it's cracked up to be?

hope
–noun
1. the feeling that what is wanted can be had or that events will turn out for the best

Nearly two decades ago, I heard a trainer in a personal effectiveness training I attended say "hope is overrated."  

I found this surprising -- St. Paul spoke very highly of it, placing it up there with faith and nearly up there with love.  So what was the problem?

I think this trainer's problem with it is that it tended to relieve a person of responsibility, the kind of responsibility that might induce the person hoping to take action in order to  have what one wanted.   To him it vested the Powerful Other (whoever that might be for a particular person) with too much power and the individual with too little.  In his mind, "I sure hope that happen" was inferior to "I will make that happen."

That made sense to me, and my early-30s self stopped giving much thought to hope.  But now, I'm believe there may be another problem with hope, a more serious one: its rootedness in the future.

This becomes quite apparent if one is practicing radical acceptance of what is.  Hope almost always presumes that what is now is not as desirable as what might be later.  To the hoper, the grass is always greener on the other side of the achievement of what is hoped for.  

Jerry Jud recently spoke of the radical step he took, after giving over his ego and his name to God, by giving over his preferences, too.  

"Thy will, not mine, be done."

What happens to hope when preferences are turned over to The One, to What Is?  

For most of us, I suspect, it is a bit of an unraveling, an existential threat to the hegemony of the ego.  

"No preferences?  You must be kidding?"

Jerry wasn't kidding, and neither am I.  

No preferences.  Therefore, no hope.

So, now, I'm trying to use hope not as a desired state, but a cautionary alarm.  When I hear myself say (or think) "I hope" with serious intent, I can notice it and ask myself, "am I fully in the present, radically accepting what is, or am I leaning toward the future, toward an alternate fantasy?  Am I clinging to my preferences, or holding them lightly?"

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Bringing the Energy of Satisfaction to Each Happening -- The Practice


A couple of days ago, I heard the founder of Shalom Mountain, Jerry Jud, say this:  "after my morning disciplines move me into a state of Satisfaction, for the rest of the day, my objective is to bring that energy of satisfaction to each happening, as it is happening, no matter what the happening is."  

I've heard some version of this a zillion times over the last three decades.  "It's not what happens to you, it's the attitude you bring to it," is another variation on this theme that I've heard a lot.

But there was something about hearing it from this 90-year-old sage who actually pratices this, lives this, that drove the point home.   Hearing this come from the lips of someone who obviously knows from the inside what it is to do this, every day, helped the point to land in my marrow.

So, what is my version of this?

Certainly, Jerry's approach of doing 90-minutes of disciplines each morning with the expressed purpose of clearing and connecting all his major energy centers is inviting.  But even short of that, I have been playing simply with breathe-attend-smile.   When it occurs to me throughout the day, as often as I can have it occur to me, I take a breath, gather my attention on what is happening in that moment, and issue a smile of satisfaction, regardless of what is happening.  

Breathe -- attend -- smile.

This evokes a version of that "energy of satisfaction" in my bodymind of which Jerry spoke.  Jerry's mantra, "I'm satisfied, Lord!" doesn't hurt, either!

Then, I imagine that this energy is associated with me, here, now, a kind of cloak or aura I carry with me into the next event, and the next, and the next.  In essence, I make my satisfaction-energy portable, and commit to bringing it with me, as I might commit to bringing a precious belonging with me on a trip.

The practice, in this form, is new to me, so I'm still stumbling.  So far, though, it seems quite promising.

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Big Mind and Tonglen with the Inner Critic

Last night's weekly practice group focused on wisdom through compassion.  One of the processes was a lovingkindness  meditation with our inner critics.  

Today, my morning cushion time took that theme and added a twist -- a blend of Big Mind and tonglen (known to our students as "giving and receiving") with my inner critic.  I used Big Mind to reify my self-critic (e.g., "I'd like to speak to the Self Critic" -- and questions such as "what is your function?" and "what gifts do you bring?").  Once the Self Critic had, in my mind's eye, a palpable existence, I practiced tonglen with him, receiving his suffering and giving him lovingkindness.  

This 20-minute process was a rich opportunity to appreciate a dimension of my Self that I often dismiss or try to suppress.  The process also seemed to put the Critic's criticism in proper context -- it is neither to be ignored nor to be the sole voice in the room.  Somehow, listening to him, then loving him, was a wonderfully healing thing to do for myself.  And my Self.


Monday, May 11, 2009

Customized Cushion Time

One of my experiments in meditation has been to explore shaping a meditation to the demands of the day, or even of the moment.  Here's how that played out today.  

This morning, as I thought about what lay ahead this day, two things arose as priorities.  First, I was scheduled for a midday introductory meeting in Baltimore with a prospective client to start examining the company's training needs and whether and how my consulting firm might be able to meet those needs.  Second, in the last couple of days I've noticed myself being dragged back into some irritated, judgmental feelings I've had toward an important person in my life.

So, the day would call for energy, wisdom, expression/listening, open-heartedness, strength, and creativity.  All chakras on deck!  In particular, felt the need to strengthen my capacity for compassion.

So, energy and chakras first:  I started with one of my favorite Tantric breathing practices.  It goes like this: 
  • Notice breath at nose/upper lip for a few breaths.  
  • On inhalation, draw awareness up to third eye, then back down to nose on exhalation, up and down that channel for a few breaths.  Then, let awareness rest in the third eye, again for a few breaths.
  • On inhalation, draw awareness back from third eye to 6th chakra, then back to third eye on exhalation, back and forth with each breath along the third eye-6th chakra channel, again for a few breaths.  Then, let awareness rest in the 6th chakra, again for a few breaths.
  • On inhalation, draw awareness down from 6th chakra to 5th (throat) chakra on inhalation, then back up to 6th on exhalation, back and forth with each breath along the 6th-5th channel, again for a few breaths.  Then, let awareness rest in the 5th chakra, again for a few breaths.
  • Repeat with each chakra down to the 2nd-root channel, then let awareness rest in the root for a few breaths.  
  • Trace with awareness the pingala nadi (see diagram here), up with the inhalation, down with the exhalation, for a few breaths.  Feel into each chakra as the awareness passes through it on its journey up and down the pingala.
  • When all chakras feel awake and energized, let this practice gently fall away.
  • Move into tonglen practice (click here for instructions by Pema Chodron) with the person with whom I've been irritated.  Along with the visualizations, add the mental-verbal expression, "I receive your suffering [inhalation], I give you my lovingkindness [exhalation]," with each breath.  Smile throughout.
I emerged from this meditation energized by the Tantric breathing.  More importantly, though, I became aware of the texture and shape of my irritation, my hardness of heart, and was aware of my heart's softening over the course of the meditation (a nearly inevitable product of tonglen, in my 13 years of experience with the practice).  

One of my particular (and peculiar) foibles is my addiction to being right, an addiction I do not remember not having.  In this morning's meditation, I saw a connection between that addiction and my irritation (as in, "I am right in being irritated -- after all, she's irritating!").  Shining the spotlight of awareness, through the compassion practice of tonglen, not only strips my righteousness naked (rendering it rather ridiculous), but also allows me to feel compassion for myself in my journey.  

All of that in 20 minutes on the cushion.  Time well spent.

Friday, May 8, 2009

Choosing from the Archetypes of Sovereign and Warrior

Once again, my ILTP group has offered up a valuable new practice tool, one that impacts me even in my absence (I was away on a business trip in Florida for our Monday meeting).

This time, after a reading of a poem by Regina Sara Ryan that invites us to reject quiet prayer in favor of praying dangerously, our leader challenged us with these questions:

Inviting in the archetypal energies of Sovereign (the one who sees and holds the vision for the realm) and the Warrior (the one who takes action and implements the plan), we explored two questions:

  1. What would you really want from life if I were absolutely, positively certain I would get it?
  2. What would you really want to accomplish in life if you were absolutely, positively certain you would do it?
  3. Where will you begin?  What is the CURRENT CHOICE?
There are times in my life as an entrepreneur when the chronic uncertainty of my chosen path seems too great to bear.  "Ahh, if only I could have a safer path for a while", I sometimes hear myself wishing (especially when my energy and spirits are low).  Forgetting that no work setting is safe from uncertainty (where is PanAm these days, anyway?), my eye starts to wander to apparently greener pastures "over there."

Ironically, this can happen, as it has in recent months, when my business is healthier than ever, when I am up to my eyeballs in work, and when prospects for growth are excellent.  Yet, this "faint-of-heart-syndrome" can come upon me even in the face of Reality.  

I need to add this -- last Saturday in our monthly meeting of the Community for Spiritual Living, I led the group in an exploration of the possibility that our "heart's desire" is multi-faceted, indeed, that each chakra might have it's own "heart's desire" that needs to be honored.  For many of us this provided an opportunity to honor the root chakra's desire for a safe place on the planet (food, shelter), the second chakra's desire for pleasure and creativity, etc., rather than saying that one desire must push aside another.  

My truth around this is that these forces need not compete with one another, although sometimes it seems like they must.  It is true that I can make a living in the world and have a spiritual practice, play music, and enjoy my time with family and friends.  

So, this week's questions about praying dangerously invite me to pray into this full life by and to conjure up a bold choice through these answers to the first two questions:

1.  What would you really want from life if I were absolutely, positively certain I would get it?

To live a largely contemplative, quiet life, with most of my time at home with my Beloved, in meditation, yoga, writing, and music.
 
2.  What would you really want to accomplish in life if you were absolutely, positively certain you would do it?

To create in myself, and therefore model for others, a peaceful heart and a life of contribution.  Specifically, I would accomplish a legacy of service through teaching, coaching, writing, and music that opens up the possibility for others of a peaceful, joyful existence in their short time on this planet.

This, then, sets up my answer Question 3, to reify this dangerous prayer in action today.

3.  Where will you begin?  What is the CURRENT CHOICE?

I commit to spending a significant portion of today to further develop my education & training and compliance modules for my business and and to practice yoga, meditation, and music.  

While I could have come up with this commitment for today without this process, the fact that it emerges from this dangerous prayer seems to root it for me at a level that is deeper than it might otherwise be.  

Tuesday, April 21, 2009

Working with States of Consciousness to Explore the "Fear Boundaries"

Our practice group started up again last night, and the theme was (as it always is the first week of the cycle) Awareness.  Our particular exploration was around exploring states of consciousness, which, as students of Ken Wilber know, are the vanguard for developmental stages of consciousness.  In other words, we can facilitate our spiritual growth (through durable stages) by exploring expansive (less durable) states of consciousness.  

In the experiential process through which James guided us, I noticed that, as I transitioned from one state to the next, more expansive state, I encountered, and then crossed a boundary marked by fear.  In other words, the exit from each state involved navigating a contraction that had the flavor of fear that was specific to that state.  Moreover, frankly, the only way I found to navigate what I will call the "fear-boundary" was to transcend the present state and move into a more inclusive state.

This is by no means the first time I have encountered this widely recognized phenomenon, but James' process highlighted it.  For example, at one point I was sitting in what one might describe as a physical-body-centered state when James invited us to allow ourselves to imagine tendrils of energy connecting us to all living beings, what is essentially an invitation into a state associated with nature mysticism.  As I allowed my imagination to create these countless connections to the entire biosphere, I found, at first, myself to be overwhelmed and fearful -- there is simply too much "out there" to connect to safely.  It became immediately apparent, though, that the fear was related to the fact that I was sitting in a "small-s self" state, one identified with the "skin bag" known as Tom.  As I allowed my sense of Self to expand to be inclusive of the biosphere, so that all of life was arising within my consciousness, the fear-boundary became irrelevant as it was within me, and no longer a boundary but merely a feature of my interior landscape.

As the old Buddhist expression says, "Where there is no Other, there is no fear."

James' closed-eye guided meditation led us through several states, each more expansive than the previous.  At each boundary, I encountered a fear-boundary that I transcended only by expanding the state of consciousness in which I was sitting to a level that could include the "Other" that was the object of the fear.  

So, my practice this week is to experiment -- through my daily meditation -- with the more salient fear-boundaries in my life.  This morning, because I'm focusing this practice cycle on service, I allowed myself to linger at the service-being boundary (what some would describe the nature-deity mysticism boundary).  I found myself noticing that the horror I sometimes experience when I contemplate the apparent cruelty of Nature (not to mention the cruelty of that portion of Nature known as humanity) was horrible only as long as I allowed it to be outside of myself.  When I cross this particular threshold and allow all of the operations of Nature (and therefore humanity) to arise within my consciousness as a part of me, my horror turned into compassion.  Compassion for the predator, not just the prey.  Compassion for the rapist, not just the raped.  Compassion for the bomber, not just the bombed.

As I said, these fear-boundaries seem to exist throughout the spectrum of states of consciousness.  However, because this particular boundary is one that seems to affect how I distill each day's love into essential service (my focus for this practice cycle), it is the one upon which I will focus for the next few weeks, at least.

Saturday, April 4, 2009

What is this practice?

Once again, my biweekly conversation with my midwestern practice buddy yielded a rich harvest.  This week's crop was the deep realization that the question, "how do I work my practice into my life?" is deeply flawed.  My life is practice already.  I am always practicing.  The better question is, "in this moment, what is my practice?"

This framing of the issue seems to be the natural result of turning the spotlight of consciousness on everything.  In our mindfulness training, we teach people how consciously to eat, walk, listen, breath, look at things, and many other activities of daily living.  Do enough of that and one may start to say, "eating is practice, walking is practice, breathing is practice, looking at this leaf is practice."

How unsettling!  This suggests that when I am in an unconscious, rageful reaction to an event or an encounter, I am practicing unconscious rage.   When I am listening tenderly to the troubles of one of my sons, I'm practicing tender, listening parenting.  When I am sitting in a Cirque du Soleil tent, agog at the performers, I am practicing awe.  

One might ask, if you are not conscious of it in the moment as practice, is it really practice?  Don't we have to think about something as practice as practice in order for it to be practice?  

My son Dustin, a skilled musician who, like many teens, balks at practicing, told me the other day that he has reframed his relationship to what once was practice time on the piano.  "I've given up practice," he explained.  "Now I just warm up and play the piano.  It's a lot more fun, and I have no resistance to that, unlike practicing."

But it's not just about changing how we hold something from "practice" to "play" or some other more palatable notion.  Rather, it is a recognition that it is all practice.  Practice is simply a behavior that, if repeated enough times, is likely to make that behavior more likely, is it not?  Seen that way, the question I get to ask myself is, "what behavior, what beliefs, what thoughts, do I want to make more likely?"  

How does this play out in real life?  Well, in my morning planning time, I can ask myself a few questions:
  • What will today's practice be?  
  • Where will I be practicing -- the office, the kitchen, in community?  
  • Are these good venues for the kind of practice I want to create today?
  • Who will be my practice partners?
This sounds pretty good, and probably is.  What sounds even better to me is to ask, as often as I can, "what am I practicing now?  What is this practice?  And this one?"  As I sit here in traffic on the Capital Beltway, am I practicing patience and lovingkindness or impatience, arrogance, and anger?  

What is this practice?  And this one?

Mere awareness of my choice of practice in each moment seems to me to be pretty likely yield at least as many benefits as 15 minutes on a cushion each morning, perhaps more.  On the other hand, I have a sneaking suspicion that this kind of moment-to-moment awareness of my practice is exactly what is likely to lead me to sit on the cushion, giving proof to the old aphorism, "meditation is not the means to enlightenment; rather, it is the natural activity of enlightened beings."  

What is this practice?

Sunday, March 29, 2009

Law of Attraction and the Shalom Process

On the Shalom Mt. community's Yahoo! listserve, a member posted an inquiry about how to reconcile the Law of Attraction's (LOA) emphasis on positive thinking and the Shalom Process (SP) approach to revisiting old wounds in order to relive them to a happier ending (to oversimplify both).  I wrote a response there that may be worth posting here:

==============
I'm far more suspicious of LOA than I am of the Shalom Process, although I'll be the first to note that SP has its limits.  My concern about LOA is that it seldom deals with the question "who is the 'self' that is doing the attracting?'  If it is the little-s "self" that simply wants a bigger house, or a sexier mate, or security in uncertain times, then it's simply, to me, a con game geared to the worst of the ego's influence on us.  And, it might 'work' in the sense that, if I'm really, really thinking hard each morning as I start my day about how to make more money, or to bag the sexier partner, or get a safer job, then, given how the human brain works, I'm very likely to do better at those tasks than someone who doesn't start each day with those affirmations.

So, LOA works, in that sense.  This is not news, though.  The most pedestrian psychologist of 50 years ago, if he had a bit of P.T. Barnum's disrespect for the American consumer, could have written The Secret.  Instead, he gave us the Bearded Lady.

The Shalom Process, on the other hand, is an authentic opportunity to explore those wounds that have become lodged in our hearts, minds, and our bodies and that keep us from our birthright of Loving and Being Loved.  Now, is it true that some of us who have been through the SP have become more enamored of our wounds than of our healing?  Yes, I believe this to be true.  Yet, I dedicate nearly all of my volunteer, charitable time to the support of this institution and this community because I believe that the various offerings of Shalom Mt. -- SP included but not exclusively -- are at the cutting edge of human healing and growth.  And, as one who has benefited from many an SP, I do not equate repeated encounters with Shadow, with ancient, disowned pain, with all the complexities of being human, as wallowing in negativity and thereby short-circuiting the LOA.  No, while I'm aware that I can love my wounds too much, I'm also aware I'm anything but fully healed.

LOA works.  But who we are when we are attracting is much more important -- and interesting -- than whether attraction works.

I offer this rant with the humility of someone struggling with the very questions with which you struggle.  I hope that the mutterings of a guy who is just-barely-not-an-ape may be of some service to you.

Friday, March 6, 2009

The Radical Embrace of All

Every other Friday, a dear friend of mine who lives in the Midwest and I talk about our respective spiritual practices.  A significant portion of this morning's conversation was around the invitation to accept and even embrace all that is.  All of it.  

This isn't a new concept in my practice.  But what unfolded in our conversation was what was for me a new slant on it.  

Think of it this way -- if Spirit (or the Divine, or God, or the Ultimate) is all and includes each human, why on earth would it/he/she forget its Selfness?  Why, in other words, would little chunks of this Great All (known to us as "humans") utterly forget that they are of the same stuff as this All, a forgetting that creats most (or even all) of human suffering?

Ken Wilber wrote about it a decade ago in his brilliant edited diary, "One Taste," when he explained, "it's no fun playing checkers alone."  One of our teachers in last weekend's Breath and Energy training at Shalom Mountain summarized it this way: for the sheer joy of the rediscovery that we are, after all that suffering, Spirit, Divine, Ultimate, All.   Before the joy of rediscovery, must come the forgetting, just as is the case if we really want to play a game of solitaire checkers, after we make each move, we must forget the strategy behind that move.  

Otherwise it's just no fun.  

So, to acceptance.  Imagine what it would be like to say, "OK, I'm in this game of Life, involving a constant forgetting then remembering of my true Selfness.   Let's play."  This is a commitment to and acceptance of the entire game, not just the moments we score points.  While true tennis players love to score points, they also love the whole game.  Same with football -- there's more that's fun about the game than touchdowns.  There's more to baseball than scoring runs.  The whole game can be worth it if we accept the entire game.

Look at the flip side -- imagine a football player who, in his heart, accepts only the moments in which his team is scoring points, and rejects the rest of the game.  This is a pretty miserable player.  And how interesting a game would football be if a touchdown were scored on every play?

Yet, there are times when I want to play only the "points scored" part of my game of Life.  How dull would that be?

So, the practice around this is a radical embrace of the entire game.  All of it.  The deep moments of forgetfulness and suffering as much as the ecstatic moments of expansive, spacious awareness of my true Self.

This is a step further than accepting/embracing the tough moments, the car breaking down on the side of the road, the angry child, the departing lover.  This is an invitation even to embrace my forgetfulness in those moments, to embrace my irritation/anger/grief in those moments.  

All of it.  

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

The Four Rivers

In last Monday's practice group, devoted to the topic of Wisdom, our leader Rick introduced us to the work of Angeles Arrien, author of The Second Half of Life: Opening the Eight Gates of Wisdom.  In particular we worked with the concept of "tracking" our lives through the four rivers of life:
  • "The River of Inspiration reveals where we are in touch with our creative fire and our life dream.  Any time that we experience expansion or hope, or feel uplifted, we are in the presence of creativity.  As long as we can still be inspired, we know we are alive, refusing to join the procession of the living dead.
  • The River of Challenge calls us to stretch and grow beyond what is knowable and familiar.  We notice who or what is asking us to leave our comfort zones and explore uncharted creative areas or interests.  This river always asks us to move past any fixed notion of what we can do.  If we are willing to be challenged, to become explorers again, acedia cannot come into our lives.
  • The River of Surprise keeps us fluid and flexible, and requires us to open to options and possibilities that we may not have considered.  The Inuits have a saying about it: ‘There are two plans for everyday, my plan and the Mystery’s plan.’  This river reveals where we have become rigid or controlling rather than curious, flexible, and ready to trust what emerges for our consideration. This river shows us where our attachments repress the natural flow of creativity and generativity.
  • The River of Love shows us where we are touched and moved by life’s experience.  If we are not, especially in our work, we know acedia is present and our heart has begun to close.  Humor, joy, laughter, and love are considered medicines for the heart by some indigenous peoples.  This river indicates that the work and service we love can make us happy.”
In the process Rick built around this concept, I noticed that, at any given point in my life, I might be tracking one or two of these "rivers", but not always all four.   On Monday, for example, I arrived at our group meeting tracking almost nothing but the River of Challenge.  As the evening unfolded, I realized I can introduced a new batch of juice into my life simply by consciously tracking my life in all four rivers.  

How?  

Periodically, perhaps when my mindfulness bell reminds me to do so, I ask the following questions, as Rick did last Monday:
  • When, in the last week, was I intouch with inspiration, the fire of my creativity?
  • When, in the last week, was I called upon to stretch beyond what I know and am comfortable with?
  • When, in the last week, was I surprised, caught off guard by the Mystery of life?
  • When, in the last week, was I moved by life's experience?
My answers, in this moment (as an example):
  • Inspiration: in a recording session Sunday with three friends.  Or the spring-like weather I've been loving the last three days.
  • Challenge: by a business setback on Monday that caused me to redouble my efforts on a couple of strategic initiatives.
  • Surprise: by a quick, unexpected, and positive turnaround in my mother's health.
  • Love: today, by the feelings of tenderness I notice in my heart as my elder son navigates a personal setback.
That took seconds, yet put me in touch with the rich diversity of my life.  There is, indeed, deep wisdom in taking time to notice the tapestry of experience that comprises a life.

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Resisting the Labeling

Rezvan and I were talking this morning about a study out of UCLA that seems to conclude that one of the main reasons mindfulness practice "works" to reduce stress is that it fosters the appropriate labeling of emotions.  While I don't doubt the research, I fear it may encourage a haste to label thoughts and emotions.  

Sure, experiencing anger and then saying "this is anger" is something we teach in our mindfulness training, a way of getting some distance from the emotion so we may witness it.  It appears that labeling an emotion activates a part of the brain that lowers the response of the amygdala, the "lizard brain" often associated with primitive, impulsive, sometimes rageful behavior.

Yet, I'm not sure this should suggest a blanket endorsement of labeling every thought or emotion that goes through one's head.  A recent conversation left me with an unidentifiable feeling around my heart area, one that I took into this morning's zazen.  Not only did I notice a curiosity arise as I was sitting -- "what is this feeling?" -- but also a ready answer: "this is sadness."  Yet, before I went with that label, I decided to simply bring awareness to the present physical, emotional, and cognitive experience.  What I noticed was a broad range of possible interpretations that included not only sadness, but fear, uncertainty, relief, joy, regret, and a few others.  By watching without clinging to one in particular, I was aware of the dance of these possible interpretations of the unlabeled sensation.  

I'm glad I held off on affixing a label too quickly.  My willingness to be in pure observation without nailing down a label afforded me a richer view of my experience than I imagine I would have had if I had seized upon "this is sadness."  Susan Campbell, PhD, the author of "Getting Real", listed as one of her 10 tips on truth-telling the willingness to share mixed emotions.  "You're not crazy, you're complex" is the subtitle of this chapter, and it expresses an essential truth.  While some emotions are clear-cut, not all are.  We need to be able to hold space for those thoughts and emotions that arise that are not easily labeled.  

So, my emotion-practice around this is -- if it's clear and unambiguous, feel free to label.  If, however, the flavor of the emotion is unclear, then simply witness the ambivalence, the swirl of competing interpretations, the dance of rising and falling emotions.  Just witness.

In either case, the invitation is to strengthen the capacity to witness what is arising in this moment, rather than have the emotion be the lens through which we view all else.  

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

Awareness of Awareness

Ever since Tara Brach's terrific mid-January all-day workshop, the theme of what she called "taking refuge in the Buddha" has been coming up. If you do a web-search on this phrase, you're likely to come up with something a bit different than her approach, which is to focus on the awareness of one's own awareness. Some might call this particular refuge-taking as developing one's capacity to rest in the Witness.

Last night, reading the final section of "Reality", by Peter Kingsley, I came across this passage, which I hope makes sense outside of its context:

[Empedocles'] first instruction to Pausanias is not to perceive but to perceive that he is perceiving -- to watch the perceptive process itself. In other words he is telling him not just to look or touch or hear but to look and touch while fully conscious of looking and touching, to hear with the awareness that he is hearing.

And anyone who starts to do this seriously will begin to become aware that what passes for ordinary human experience is nothing but a dream.

The next several paragraphs also are worth reading, but I'll not repeat them here.  But check this out:  

If he were instructing him not only to look but to become aware at the same time of looking, that would be important enough.  He is not, though.  He is explaining to him that as well of being aware of whatever he is seeing he also has to be aware of every single thing he is hearing; touching; tasting; feeling.  

Nothing is to be left out.  Not the slightest preference is to be shown to one sense as opposed to any other.  And this choiceless, all-embracing awareness can only happen in one particular moment: right now. 

Back in graduate school I learned about meta-cognition -- thinking about thinking.  This approach is far broader -- meta-perception, meta-emotion, meta-awareness.  Breathtaking, really.  

This take on things is influencing everything from my teaching to my meetings with clients to my conversations with friends and family.   Not that I'm in this state of choiceless awareness in every moment, but the number of moments in any day in which I am has risen exponentially recently.   And not through teeth-grinding effort, either.  Kingsley has something to say about this almost effortless acceleration:

Few things could seem to demand more effort than the process of getting used to this awareness.  But nothing is more effortless than the awareness itself.  And what had looked impossible to begin with becomes easier with time because even though each moment of awareness is only an awareness in the one moment.   Metis is like an organism that actually nourishes itself.  

This "metis" of which Kingsley speaks is a peculiar slant on wisdom:

Metis was the Greek term for cunning, skillfulness, practical intelligence; and especially for trickery.  . . .  It meant a particular quality of intense awareness that always manages to stay focused on the whole: on the lookout for hints, however subtle, for guidance in whatever form it happens to take, for signs of the route to follow however quickly they might appear or disappear.

And it seems to be organic, probably because there's this positive feedback loop embedded in witnessing.  In those moments of awareness of awareness, the clarity is so radically different than the dream of ordinary human existence, the Mind (heart? soul?) seems to take note so that the path back to that clarity is easier the next time.

So what's that practice again, Tom?  Very simply, awareness of awareness.

If you haven't already done so, try it!  The water's fine!

Sunday, February 1, 2009

Curiosity Killed the Clinging

A few months ago, one of my practice group fellows invited the rest of the group into the practice of curiosity. "Tell me more about that" was the phrase that started to emerge in my conversations.

This has turned out to be a surprisingly powerful practice in more ways than it initially appeared, and arose again in last week's work around "Letting Go". In my work with a dyad partner who is also a parent, I looked into the issue of parental inquiry -- to what extent do my questions of my sons reflect a genuine curiosity -- one with no Tom-agenda? Or, on the other hand, how often do I ask questions simply to make a parental point that is related to my sometimes ego-driven aspirations for them?

Curiosity -- genuine inquiry -- tends to invite me into an authentic embrace of what is, or what Tara Brach might call taking refuge in the Dharma. More interestingly for my practice, though, is my inquiry into my state of consciousness itself. By asking myself, "am I really being curious here?", I shine my spotlight of consciousness on my consciousness itself, what Tara might categorize as taking refuge in the Buddha.

The awareness of my state of consciousness -- in this case, my level of authentic curiosity -- is my cutting edge for this week.

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Interrupting Reactivity with Implementation Intentions and Mindfulness

In this short video, I describe a new practice (new to me, at least) that occurred to me in the midst of last weekend's Tara Brach all-day mindfulness retreat in Bethesda, MD. It is a blend of a habit-modification practice developed in the 1990s by Peter Gollwitzer called "Implementation Intentions" and a visualization process taught by Jack Kornfield and Tara.

Friday, January 16, 2009

More on Minimization Practice

A few days ago (12/30/08) I wrote about minimizing as a way to keep expectations in line with the demands of the day while filling the day with loving, mindful practice.  As I go through my morning routine of looking ahead, I'm realizing that there are times, like today, that I need to see the broader picture in order to scale my practice.  

Here's what I mean.  My calendar over the next eight days is booked.  I mean booked.  Conference calls from 10-5 today.  An all-day mindfulness workshop tomorrow.  A 2-hour planning session with Rezvan for our mindfulness training, a visit with my parents and the NFL conference championships Sunday (yes, I've scheduled time for the best football games of the year!).  Then, a four-day business trip to central Michigan, followed next Friday by a day half filled with calls and half filled with the first day of our next round of mindfulness trainings at NIH.

Now, I'm not complaining.  I not only chose all of this, I love all of this. It's just that I would do well to see it all in context, together.  Should I accept a dear friend's dinner invitation in this middle of this?  No.  Should I make a task list for the weekend?  No, not unless it looks like:
  • Exercise
  • Pack
The truth is that my heart and soul require that I set all my task-oriented ambition aside, forget about fears that I'll come off as uncaring, and tend to my life for a few days.  The next eight days can be a glorious opportunity to meditate, enjoy family, and be of service to clients, or I can emerge stressed, battered, and over-scheduled.  

Choosing the former will require that I see the whole period in context and minimize, minimize, minimize.  

With love, of course.

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Developing the Conscious-Flexibility Muscle

Our Integral Life and Transformational Practice Group ("ILTP") reconvened last night for the first evening of our fifth, 7-session cycle.  We are now eight, which seems a perfect size -- just enough diversity, yet not so large as to be impersonal.  

We rotate process facilitation, and last night was my evening to lead.  The topic of the first week, as it is every cycle, was "Awareness."  At the heart of the evening was an experiment in practicing flexibility in moving consciousness from one anchor to another.  I took two rather straightforward process from the Mindfulness and Stress Reduction training that Rezvan and I lead at NIH -- "Sound as Anchor" and Thoughts as Anchor" -- and put them back-to-back, with no break in between.  So, the participants were invited, after 12 minutes of delicious and soul-expanding meditation on sounds, to shift the spotlight of their attention to focus on whatever thoughts arose, moment-to-moment.

For some, but not all, it was jarring.  Understandably.  Which is exactly the reason I'm going to experiment in the coming days with this sort of focus-shifting practice.  I, like my fellow practitioners, sometimes have favorite mindfulness practices.  These days, I like Shikantaza better than body scan, sound-as-anchor better than yoga, etc., etc.  Indeed, within a single practice I have preferable experiences -- I might like last Tuesday's experience of Shikantaza better than this morning's.  

Practice is like life -- full of preferences.   

Which is fine, so long as I don't take these preferences particularly seriously, clinging to them.  

But sometimes I do.  When I do, there invariably is some sort of discomfort or suffering.  In fact, clinging to preferences, the Buddha said in his first post-enlightenment sermon, is the source of all human suffering.

So, it seems there might be some value in practicing -- intentionally -- shifting practices from the comfortable to the uncomfortable, exposing to the light of day my preferences (and accompanying clinging), and letting go.

That is why, in addition to my normal practice this week, it is my intention to -- at least once -- set two (and maybe more) mindfulness practices adjacent to each other and observe the discomfort that may arise from the shift from one to the next.

If this sounds more like play than practice, good.  Who doesn't like a play group?

Friday, January 9, 2009

Service Practice

As I scan my schedule for today, I could imagine how one interpretation could be "no time for practice today."  The client conference calls start at about 9:45 a.m., and continue without a scheduled break until 5:00 p.m.  Yet, I don't see it that way.  I see a terrific opportunity to practice all day, so long as I gear my practice toward being in loving service to my clients all day long.

Now, I can make this more likely to be a practice rather than a chore by preparing for it.  For example, while I may not be able to do every component of my usual morning practice routine, there will be some essential elements that I will not forego:
  • Yoga
  • Meditation
  • Exercise (today, that means high intensity interval training)
  • Mindful eating of a substantial, healthful breakfast
As important as all of that is to firmly set my intention about these conference calls.  For that, I fall back on the focus I set for this cycle of my Integral Life and Transformational Practice Group:  
  • I live each day out of my highest self, in service to all.
I have that written on a small piece of paper taped to the top of my monitor, lest I forget that in the fifth or sixth hour of client calls.

Oh, and in case I miss the point, a couple of inches to the right of that reminder, I've also taped a reminder of what I mean by "highest self":
  • Big Mind, Big Heart
The prospects for the day seem quite bright when framed this way.  

Yum.

Thursday, January 8, 2009

Travel Practice -- Mindful in Times Square


I confess off the bat that I haven't settled on a particular practice while I'm traveling.  Monday through Wednesday of this week I was in New York City on business, and there wasn't much room (either in my room or my calendar) for the same sort of practice I engage in at home. 

What do you do with a schedule that looks like this:

Monday
3:30-6 -- wake up, pack, drive to train station
6-10 -- travel to client office in Manhattan
10-5 -- work at client office
6-8 -- dinner with colleague

Tuesday
8-9 -- breakfast with colleague and travel to client office
9-5 -- work at client office
7:30-9:30 -- conference calls

Wednesday
9-12:30 -- work at client office
1-4:30 -- travel back to DC

So, what's a practitioner to do?  As you might imagine, a schedule like this allows little room for leisurely yoga, meditation, and exercise sessions.  I did a double exercise session in the hotel fitness center Tuesday morning from 6-7:30 (since I had no exercise Monday), but that's about it for carved-out practice time.  

The trick for me is to find micro-practices throughout the time.  I did what I could to squeeze in 10-minute closed-eye Tantric breathing and visualization times on the train trips, 30-second breathing at the client office, 5-second gratitude practices at critical junctures (esp. meals), and other pause-to-be-mindful moments into my schedule.  

So, on crammed days like these, it was particularly helpful to have some training in mindful walking, mindful eating, mindful communication, and the like.

Friday, January 2, 2009

Tantric Preparation

I will be attending the Advanced Tantra Training at Shalom Mountain in February.  In anticipation, the Mountain sent me a series of CDs with preparatory tantric guided meditations to get us ready for the training.  

I dove in this morning with the first preparatory practice.  It is taken from one of the basic texts, one which I acquired when I went through the three-weekend Basic Tantra training last winter, Prana Pranayama, Prana Vidya, by Swami Niranjanananda Saraswati.  Today's practice was comprised of Stage I, Stage II, and Stage III of the practices designed to develop awareness of the psychic passages, from pp. 270--272 of that book.  I won't spell out the practices here because it is useful to have some background, either from earlier chapters of the book or from an introductory training in tantric breathing and energy techniques, before diving into them.  

I'm very glad to be turning toward Tantra again after a few months of a practice more focused on Zen and Vipassana.  In my 3 decades+ history of meditation, I have yet to encounter anything quite like tantric energy and breathing practices.  There is something uniquely grounding and energizing about Tantra.

The rest of my practice focus for today looks something like this:

Body:  Yoga, HIIT, and an abs workout.
Mind:  Reading (still working on Reality)
Service:  Preparing for a couple of upcoming client engagements in NYC and MI; some writing about quality standards in case management organizations and mail service pharmacies; a bit of work for a non-profit foundation that I serve as an Executive Committee member.
Art/Music:  More work on the recording studio; helping my son record; practice Persian tar.
Finance:  Handle some beginning-of-year business financial and legal matters.
Family:  Schedule family outings to Cirque du Soliel and the Smithsonian.

Time permitting, I may do a bit of shadow work (probably Integral Life's 3-2-1-0 approach) around some family issues that arose over the last couple of days.  If not today, certainly sometime this weekend, as I don't want this stuff hanging around much longer!

Yes, I consider all of this practice, since all of it provides me an opportunity to live today -- all day -- out of my highest self in service to all.