Showing posts with label witness. Show all posts
Showing posts with label witness. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Resisting the Labeling

Rezvan and I were talking this morning about a study out of UCLA that seems to conclude that one of the main reasons mindfulness practice "works" to reduce stress is that it fosters the appropriate labeling of emotions.  While I don't doubt the research, I fear it may encourage a haste to label thoughts and emotions.  

Sure, experiencing anger and then saying "this is anger" is something we teach in our mindfulness training, a way of getting some distance from the emotion so we may witness it.  It appears that labeling an emotion activates a part of the brain that lowers the response of the amygdala, the "lizard brain" often associated with primitive, impulsive, sometimes rageful behavior.

Yet, I'm not sure this should suggest a blanket endorsement of labeling every thought or emotion that goes through one's head.  A recent conversation left me with an unidentifiable feeling around my heart area, one that I took into this morning's zazen.  Not only did I notice a curiosity arise as I was sitting -- "what is this feeling?" -- but also a ready answer: "this is sadness."  Yet, before I went with that label, I decided to simply bring awareness to the present physical, emotional, and cognitive experience.  What I noticed was a broad range of possible interpretations that included not only sadness, but fear, uncertainty, relief, joy, regret, and a few others.  By watching without clinging to one in particular, I was aware of the dance of these possible interpretations of the unlabeled sensation.  

I'm glad I held off on affixing a label too quickly.  My willingness to be in pure observation without nailing down a label afforded me a richer view of my experience than I imagine I would have had if I had seized upon "this is sadness."  Susan Campbell, PhD, the author of "Getting Real", listed as one of her 10 tips on truth-telling the willingness to share mixed emotions.  "You're not crazy, you're complex" is the subtitle of this chapter, and it expresses an essential truth.  While some emotions are clear-cut, not all are.  We need to be able to hold space for those thoughts and emotions that arise that are not easily labeled.  

So, my emotion-practice around this is -- if it's clear and unambiguous, feel free to label.  If, however, the flavor of the emotion is unclear, then simply witness the ambivalence, the swirl of competing interpretations, the dance of rising and falling emotions.  Just witness.

In either case, the invitation is to strengthen the capacity to witness what is arising in this moment, rather than have the emotion be the lens through which we view all else.  

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

Awareness of Awareness

Ever since Tara Brach's terrific mid-January all-day workshop, the theme of what she called "taking refuge in the Buddha" has been coming up. If you do a web-search on this phrase, you're likely to come up with something a bit different than her approach, which is to focus on the awareness of one's own awareness. Some might call this particular refuge-taking as developing one's capacity to rest in the Witness.

Last night, reading the final section of "Reality", by Peter Kingsley, I came across this passage, which I hope makes sense outside of its context:

[Empedocles'] first instruction to Pausanias is not to perceive but to perceive that he is perceiving -- to watch the perceptive process itself. In other words he is telling him not just to look or touch or hear but to look and touch while fully conscious of looking and touching, to hear with the awareness that he is hearing.

And anyone who starts to do this seriously will begin to become aware that what passes for ordinary human experience is nothing but a dream.

The next several paragraphs also are worth reading, but I'll not repeat them here.  But check this out:  

If he were instructing him not only to look but to become aware at the same time of looking, that would be important enough.  He is not, though.  He is explaining to him that as well of being aware of whatever he is seeing he also has to be aware of every single thing he is hearing; touching; tasting; feeling.  

Nothing is to be left out.  Not the slightest preference is to be shown to one sense as opposed to any other.  And this choiceless, all-embracing awareness can only happen in one particular moment: right now. 

Back in graduate school I learned about meta-cognition -- thinking about thinking.  This approach is far broader -- meta-perception, meta-emotion, meta-awareness.  Breathtaking, really.  

This take on things is influencing everything from my teaching to my meetings with clients to my conversations with friends and family.   Not that I'm in this state of choiceless awareness in every moment, but the number of moments in any day in which I am has risen exponentially recently.   And not through teeth-grinding effort, either.  Kingsley has something to say about this almost effortless acceleration:

Few things could seem to demand more effort than the process of getting used to this awareness.  But nothing is more effortless than the awareness itself.  And what had looked impossible to begin with becomes easier with time because even though each moment of awareness is only an awareness in the one moment.   Metis is like an organism that actually nourishes itself.  

This "metis" of which Kingsley speaks is a peculiar slant on wisdom:

Metis was the Greek term for cunning, skillfulness, practical intelligence; and especially for trickery.  . . .  It meant a particular quality of intense awareness that always manages to stay focused on the whole: on the lookout for hints, however subtle, for guidance in whatever form it happens to take, for signs of the route to follow however quickly they might appear or disappear.

And it seems to be organic, probably because there's this positive feedback loop embedded in witnessing.  In those moments of awareness of awareness, the clarity is so radically different than the dream of ordinary human existence, the Mind (heart? soul?) seems to take note so that the path back to that clarity is easier the next time.

So what's that practice again, Tom?  Very simply, awareness of awareness.

If you haven't already done so, try it!  The water's fine!