Sunday, May 31, 2009

Hope: All it's cracked up to be?

hope
–noun
1. the feeling that what is wanted can be had or that events will turn out for the best

Nearly two decades ago, I heard a trainer in a personal effectiveness training I attended say "hope is overrated."  

I found this surprising -- St. Paul spoke very highly of it, placing it up there with faith and nearly up there with love.  So what was the problem?

I think this trainer's problem with it is that it tended to relieve a person of responsibility, the kind of responsibility that might induce the person hoping to take action in order to  have what one wanted.   To him it vested the Powerful Other (whoever that might be for a particular person) with too much power and the individual with too little.  In his mind, "I sure hope that happen" was inferior to "I will make that happen."

That made sense to me, and my early-30s self stopped giving much thought to hope.  But now, I'm believe there may be another problem with hope, a more serious one: its rootedness in the future.

This becomes quite apparent if one is practicing radical acceptance of what is.  Hope almost always presumes that what is now is not as desirable as what might be later.  To the hoper, the grass is always greener on the other side of the achievement of what is hoped for.  

Jerry Jud recently spoke of the radical step he took, after giving over his ego and his name to God, by giving over his preferences, too.  

"Thy will, not mine, be done."

What happens to hope when preferences are turned over to The One, to What Is?  

For most of us, I suspect, it is a bit of an unraveling, an existential threat to the hegemony of the ego.  

"No preferences?  You must be kidding?"

Jerry wasn't kidding, and neither am I.  

No preferences.  Therefore, no hope.

So, now, I'm trying to use hope not as a desired state, but a cautionary alarm.  When I hear myself say (or think) "I hope" with serious intent, I can notice it and ask myself, "am I fully in the present, radically accepting what is, or am I leaning toward the future, toward an alternate fantasy?  Am I clinging to my preferences, or holding them lightly?"

1 comment:

Unknown said...

Nicely done. As I reflect on your notes I am wondering if there is another more inclusive frame on hope.

Could there be an all levels and all quadrants view that recognizes the future focused hope, but also radically accepts the desire/hope that as our practice becomes more and more our center and natural that we will change and grow and develop and mature? I could see how this desire and hope is the desire that we can learn from the pain and suffering of our past hopes, and trust/hope that by letting go of a false hope in the future that we can have hope or peace right now....

Could it be that radical acceptance of what is, is a radical hope that transforms our resistance into a peace that passes all understanding? To me all of this is the radical truth and power of One Taste, a complete contact or union with the now, the present, what is, the "I am." And that is enough.

Oh that my true self, my central self, might come to know and understand that One Taste is enough, it is what liberates me and all beings into the such-ness of this and every moment....