This framing of the issue seems to be the natural result of turning the spotlight of consciousness on everything. In our mindfulness training, we teach people how consciously to eat, walk, listen, breath, look at things, and many other activities of daily living. Do enough of that and one may start to say, "eating is practice, walking is practice, breathing is practice, looking at this leaf is practice."
How unsettling! This suggests that when I am in an unconscious, rageful reaction to an event or an encounter, I am practicing unconscious rage. When I am listening tenderly to the troubles of one of my sons, I'm practicing tender, listening parenting. When I am sitting in a Cirque du Soleil tent, agog at the performers, I am practicing awe.
One might ask, if you are not conscious of it in the moment as practice, is it really practice? Don't we have to think about something as practice as practice in order for it to be practice?
My son Dustin, a skilled musician who, like many teens, balks at practicing, told me the other day that he has reframed his relationship to what once was practice time on the piano. "I've given up practice," he explained. "Now I just warm up and play the piano. It's a lot more fun, and I have no resistance to that, unlike practicing."
But it's not just about changing how we hold something from "practice" to "play" or some other more palatable notion. Rather, it is a recognition that it is all practice. Practice is simply a behavior that, if repeated enough times, is likely to make that behavior more likely, is it not? Seen that way, the question I get to ask myself is, "what behavior, what beliefs, what thoughts, do I want to make more likely?"
How does this play out in real life? Well, in my morning planning time, I can ask myself a few questions:
- What will today's practice be?
- Where will I be practicing -- the office, the kitchen, in community?
- Are these good venues for the kind of practice I want to create today?
- Who will be my practice partners?
What is this practice? And this one?
Mere awareness of my choice of practice in each moment seems to me to be pretty likely yield at least as many benefits as 15 minutes on a cushion each morning, perhaps more. On the other hand, I have a sneaking suspicion that this kind of moment-to-moment awareness of my practice is exactly what is likely to lead me to sit on the cushion, giving proof to the old aphorism, "meditation is not the means to enlightenment; rather, it is the natural activity of enlightened beings."
What is this practice?