Sunday, April 11, 2010

Self Awareness and Self Responsiveness

Much is made of self-awareness. Dogen lifted it up the study of the self as being identical with the study of the Way.

To study the Way is to study the self. To study the self is to forget the self. To forget the self is to be enlightened by all things of the universe. To be enlightened by all things of the universe is to cast off the body and mind of the self as well as those of others. Even the traces of enlightenment are wiped out, and life with traceless enlightenment goes on forever and ever.

It seems, though, that self-awareness is insufficient. We also need a self-responsiveness. Think of the action of driving a car. It is not sufficient to keep our eyes and ears open when we drive; rather, we must also steer and brake the car in response to what we see and hear.

This occurs to me this Sunday morning, my second since moving into solitude in the mountains of New York, because I did a radical thing: at about 10:30 a.m., when I became aware that I was tired, I took a 75 minute nap. I responded to my awareness of my tiredness.

Why is this radical? Because, as I look back over my life, I have almost never done this except when on vacation. And I am not on vacation. In fact, I have quite a long task list today: expense reports to complete, invoices to send to clients, work to do for other clients, and filing an extension for my taxes.

Why is it such a rare thing for me to respond in this way to such a basic need as rest? The easy answer would be "other people." The expectations of others -- in my family, workplace, culture -- make such a late-morning nap odd at the least, perhaps a sign of an ill-spent evening the night before or, even worse, the deadly sin of Sloth.

Perhaps, also, the activities of others prevent this self-responsiveness: the thumping of teenage boys, the lively conversation of loved ones, perhaps even a stereo or TV. So, only in the absence of other people am I free to respond to myself. There is a kind of comfort in knowing that I have been chronically unresponsive to my own needs because of the intervention of other people. The solution in such a scenario is simple -- avoid other people.

Yet, seeing that as the only solution leaves out the possibility of transformation of relationships. Imagine, for a moment, if I decided to communicate to the people with whom I live, work, and recreate that I am the sort of person who responds to my needs:
  • I sleep when I'm tired.
  • I awake when I'm rested.
  • I eat when I'm hungry.
  • I withdraw when I'm feeling the need for solitude.
  • I make music when my own song bubbles up to the surface.
  • I weep when I am sad.
This might involve a radical transformation of some, if not most, relationships. And that would be only the first step. I might also have to negotiate with these people in order to be able to do this in community. We'd have to have a discussion, perhaps, about the conditions I need in order to be able to be self-responsive.

But wait, there's more! This no doubt would get some of the people in my relationships to say things like, "well, what about my needs? I'd like to sleep when I'm tired, too, and I cannot do that when you're singing a Verde aria!" This could erupt into open negotiations among people about how to get our needs met. We might need to ask each other for help in meeting our needs. This might even involve negotiating fundamental changes in how I live, work, and play in community, changes that make it more likely that all of us will get more of our needs met.

Why is this not happening with greater frequency now? One of the reasons, I believe, is because of the stories we tell ourselves and each other about getting our needs met. "It's selfish. It's narcissistic. It's hedonistic." And, in the face of those stories, we tuck our needs away, one at a time, until we're dragging ourselves around, drained, physically and emotionally, resentful, angry, and wondering where the juice of our lives went.

Another is because we are afraid of the "no" we expect to get when we ask for the meeting of our needs. Our fear of "no", in essence, provides us with the "no" without even asking. I get to resent you for your "no" even though you've not given it to me.

So, today I vow to practice both self-awareness and self-responsiveness. Of course, it will be easier when, on days like today, I'm likely to be alone most of the day, kind of like riding a bike with training wheels on an empty cul-de-sac. I'll watch, I'll listen, and I'll respond, taking baby steps.

Once I get good at that, perhaps I'll know better how to start redesigning my relationships so that, not only will I have my needs met, but so will my beloveds, co-workers, and play mates.

Some of you reading this have already fully accomplished this in your lives. I ask you to share (or at least reflect on) your experiences: What worked, what didn't, what obstacles did you encounter along the way?

Others of you, like me, have accomplished this in some domains but not others. You, I ask to share or reflect on the characteristics of these domains. What conditions make it more likely that you can have these kinds of relationships?

Still others seldom, if ever, feel free to act on your own needs. You I invite to survey your domain and ask, "where can I start? Where can I begin to carve out a life that is that free." Remember, it doesn't have to be all at once.

OK, enough of that. I don't feel like writing anymore. I feel like walking in the warm sun and enjoying this glorious spring day.

Bye!

Monday, March 8, 2010

The call to wake up

There's something deepening in my capacity to see every irritation, disappointment, or anger as a call to wake up. The irritation -- once recognized -- provokes the inquiry, "What was my expectation? What is the nature of my addiction to that expectation?" The inquiry, coupled with breath and attention, seems to be enough.

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Insert the Big Rocks First

There's an old story -- perhaps recounted by Steven Covey -- about how to put a bunch of large and small rocks into a jar. Let's assume that they will exactly fill the jar if put in properly. If you put the small rocks in the first, you won't be able to get all of the large rocks in. To make it work, you have to put the large rocks into the jar first. The small rocks will then fill in all of the cracks. Do it in the wrong order in several large rocks are likely to be left out.
This morning, as I entered Day Two of the 90-day sit, I remembered this in connection with my effort to figure out how to make sure I got my full 60 minutes of seated meditation into my schedule. Historically, when I have done "big rocks first" schedule planning, I've counted only events like client phone calls or meetings as the "big rocks," with everything else as small rocks. The tacit assumption in this approach, however, is that only client meetings really matter. No wonder things like meditation and music get minimized or omitted altogether.
Today I treated every one of my Ango commitments (see March 1 post) as a big rock, along with my client meetings. I did this, not just for today, but ad infinitum, via the mechanism of the recurring appointments feature of my Google calendar. I'll keep you posted on how it goes. So far, though, by 9 a.m., I'm on schedule (and the yoga, the first sit and the music are already done).

Monday, March 1, 2010

Ango: Intensive Practice in Community

Ango is a 90- to 100-day period of intense study and meditation in community. With its roots in the Zen tradition, Ango came into my life as a student at Zen Mountain Monastery in Mt. Tremper, NY.

My Spring Ango this year will be online: iEvolve's "90 sits in 90 days". In this, people who dive in commit to at least 60 minutes of meditation each day for 90 consecutive days, starting today, March 1. The 60 minutes can be at one or several sittings -- I'll be doing mine in three, 20-minute sits.

In the spirit of ZMM's approach to Ango, though, I made a series of declarations of intention for this Ango across all eight of the "Gates of Zen" outlined by ZMM's late Abbott, Daido Loori. Here's a summary of my declarations for this Ango:
  • Zazen (60 minutes per day)
  • Study with a teacher (Victor Landa in March and Shugen Sensei in April and May)
  • Academic study (Bhagavad-Gita and Shobogenzo)
  • Liturgy (mainly in 8 periods of prayer and study per day)
  • Right Action (mindfulness and Respectful Confrontation trainings and workshops)
  • Art practice (daily music and monthly painting)
  • Body practice (yoga, ILP kata, and walking; weight training starts in April)
  • Work practice (launching a new online training course in health quality standards; attending to a host a new clients in my consulting firm)
Participation in iEvolve's 90-day program is free and open to anyone who wants to give it a shot. Click here to sign up.

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Open Space

The phrase, "open space," keeps arising in my awareness. I have been thinking a lot about where my practice is, and this phrase keeps popping up in my thoughts. I have often interpreted it recently as a reduction of busy-ness, simplifying, focusing on the essential and letting all else fall away. And that is one meaning that resonates.

Just within the last 24 hours I've encountered two readings that flesh out, broaden, the notion of open space. First, Eckhart Tolle, in his 2005 book, A New Earth, writes about a woman with whom he worked on her general unhappiness and pain. After some period of resistance, she finally accepts his invitation to focus her attention on what she was feeling in her body, to sense her emotion directly, unfiltered by her unhappy thoughts. At a certain point in the encounter, Tolle experiences a shift in her energy field, at which time she reports, "This is weird. I'm still unhappy, but now there is space around it. It seems to matter less."

Space.

Only hours later, on my flight to Houston, I read this in the great Zen teacher Dogen's Shobogenzo [I've done a bit of translation from Sanskrit to English for clarity's sake]:

When enlightened people want to research perfect wisdom, they should research it as space. So researching wisdom is space itself. Space is the research of wisdom.


Moments ago, in this morning's first meditation, I experienced thoughts as arising within space. A thought would arise and seemingly attempt to seduce me into identification with it. Because I was resting in a vast Space, however, or "Boundless Mind", I did not "become" either these thoughts or even the thinker of these thoughts. Rather, the experience was of being a Great Space within which thinkers of thoughts generated one thought after an another. Even the thought "when I finish this period of sitting, I'll get up and journal about space" was generated not so much by me as by a thinker of that thought within the Open Space in which I abide.

So, the invitation today is into a Great Spaciousness.

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Reminders, reminders, reminders

Years ago, shortly after I first became mindful of mindfulness, it became obvious to me that I was mindful sometimes and not so mindful other times, that I was fully in the present moment one moment, and distracted by the past or future in the next. It was about then, in a Zen monastery in New York, that I became aware of the notion that one aim of practice was to infuse each day with constant mindfulness, throughout the day. "Ceaseless practice" was the name for it.

I've since come to realize that this is better held as a statement of what is than yet another goal to set -- and then fail at achieving. By that I mean that even the seemingly mindless stumbling through a day, tossed about by thoughts of past and future, is itself practice.

However, setting that revised definition of ceaseless practice aside, I still see that the quality of any given day is noticeably affected by the extent to which I remind myself to be mindful, firmly rooted in the Now, throughout the day.

For me to do that, though, requires that I not only set an intent to be that, but to remind myself of that intent. Various faiths have provided ideas about how to do this -- the use of beads as some version of a call to practice can be found in Islam, Christianity, Hinduism, and Buddhism. Christian monastic communities have established "offices" -- times throughout the day dedicated to chanting, prayer, and reading of sacred texts. Muslims pray five times throughout the day. The Washington Mindfulness Community has a "mindfulness bell" on its website, one that you can set to ring either at regular or at random intervals, bells to call the practitioner back to his/her breath. Teachers of practice, both cleric and lay, have been creative in devising ways to call the practitioner back to center, essentially a call to come home.

Much of my recent practice has been centered around consciously and creatively devising for myself a system of such calls to practice. This has involved all of the tools I describe above, and others, changing the system frequently so as not to become inured (and unconscious) to one particular set of reminders. Among my set of tools:
  • Scheduling 5-10 minute breaks throughout the day, quite like the monastic offices, to read and meditate;
  • Beads, either in my pocket or around my wrist;
  • A smooth stone in my pocket;
  • The aforementioned Mindfulness Bell;
  • Certain rituals at various times of the day to which I adhere: yoga and meditation upon awakening, a Friday, 10 a.m. call to a close friend to tell each other about our respective practices, a daily writing of a Mindfulness Nugget to send to a listserve of current and former students and friends;
  • Various essential personal communities, from my monthly men's group to my weekly practice group;
  • Certain aspects of my work itself, including preparation for and leadership of the two mindfulness groups that Rezvan and I lead each week.
With this constellation of practices and habits, I'm seldom far from a reminder that calls me home. The more I take this on, the more infused my day is with a sense of peace and of being at home, comfortable in my skin, in communities of people through which I move, and in my world.

So, while I'm no longer neurotically driven to achieve some notion of ceaseless practice (as I was as a beginner practitioner), I'm enjoying the gradual transformation of my life that is resulting from a daily commitment to call myself, over and over again, back to Self, back to Now, back to Here.

Sunday, January 3, 2010

Karma

A friend of mine just wrote me with an inquiry about karma. She read something about it and her curiosity was piqued, sensing that she might be able to make some positive changes in her life if she just understood this better.

Here is what I wrote:

Dear M. . .

Well, at its heart, karma is the law of cause and effect. Every cause has an effect that ripples endlessly throughout time and space. The consequence of this cuts two ways. First, each of your actions has an infinite number of effects. Being mindful of this basic law is perhaps the most important thing one can do about it. With mindfulness comes an enhanced capacity to choose clearly among courses of action. So, the study of mindfulness is an excellent place to start with this aspect of karma. This is what we teach at NIH, and, while our source material comes from a broad array of authors, the most important is likely Jon Kabat-Zinn. Among his books, I recommend Full Catastrophe Living, Wherever You Go There You Are, and Coming to Our Senses: Healing Ourselves and the World Through Mindfulness. He also has a mindfulness cd you can download, Mindfulness for Beginners

Let me be clear: reading the books won't do it. This is not something to study like economics or history. This is something to study like a violin--by doing it. So, the purpose of the books is to teach you how to do the exercises, and not so much to give you understanding so that you can be smarter about this.

The second consequence of karma is that your current situation is the product of an infinite number of causes. By definition, these have all happened in the past and are therefore out of your control. This is not fatalism--this is fact. All that is--right now--is beyond your present control. While you may have some influence over the next moment, based on what you do in this moment, the context in which you take that next action is a given: it's already been provided. Some of your present situation has been provided by you and your decisions; some of your present situation has provided by others and their decisions. Because all of these causes are in the past, they are, in this moment, out of your control.

Therefore, a very important learning from the law of karma is bound up in acceptance. Tara Brach, a teacher from around this area, has written a book called Radical Acceptance. she also has a CD of guided meditations. The practice of radical acceptance of all that is is not easy, yet it is essential, for as long as we fight against that over which we have no control, we will suffer.

The Serenity Prayer has been very helpful for me in the last few months, as I believe I have told you. It is particularly powerful when practiced in the context of Radical Acceptance. When faced with a sense of powerlessness, and the associated anger and/or frustration, my practice has been to return to the question, "what can I do?" There is much I cannot do, and if I focus on that, I will remain locked in a prison of my own making. There is, however, much I can do, in this moment, once I have fully accepted all that has led up to this moment.

Again, the key is practice, not understanding. Daily, repetitive, diligent practice. There is a story: a boy became interested in history, so he read all of the books he could get his hands on and became a historian. He then became interested in economics, read all the books he could get his hands on, and became an economist. He then became interested in swimming, read all the books he could get his hands on, and drowned.

I leave you with a prayer by Dag Hammarskjöld: For all that has been ... Thanks. For all that will be ... Yes!

This is a blend of radical acceptance and an openness to what's next.

Love,

Tom