Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Reminders, reminders, reminders

Years ago, shortly after I first became mindful of mindfulness, it became obvious to me that I was mindful sometimes and not so mindful other times, that I was fully in the present moment one moment, and distracted by the past or future in the next. It was about then, in a Zen monastery in New York, that I became aware of the notion that one aim of practice was to infuse each day with constant mindfulness, throughout the day. "Ceaseless practice" was the name for it.

I've since come to realize that this is better held as a statement of what is than yet another goal to set -- and then fail at achieving. By that I mean that even the seemingly mindless stumbling through a day, tossed about by thoughts of past and future, is itself practice.

However, setting that revised definition of ceaseless practice aside, I still see that the quality of any given day is noticeably affected by the extent to which I remind myself to be mindful, firmly rooted in the Now, throughout the day.

For me to do that, though, requires that I not only set an intent to be that, but to remind myself of that intent. Various faiths have provided ideas about how to do this -- the use of beads as some version of a call to practice can be found in Islam, Christianity, Hinduism, and Buddhism. Christian monastic communities have established "offices" -- times throughout the day dedicated to chanting, prayer, and reading of sacred texts. Muslims pray five times throughout the day. The Washington Mindfulness Community has a "mindfulness bell" on its website, one that you can set to ring either at regular or at random intervals, bells to call the practitioner back to his/her breath. Teachers of practice, both cleric and lay, have been creative in devising ways to call the practitioner back to center, essentially a call to come home.

Much of my recent practice has been centered around consciously and creatively devising for myself a system of such calls to practice. This has involved all of the tools I describe above, and others, changing the system frequently so as not to become inured (and unconscious) to one particular set of reminders. Among my set of tools:
  • Scheduling 5-10 minute breaks throughout the day, quite like the monastic offices, to read and meditate;
  • Beads, either in my pocket or around my wrist;
  • A smooth stone in my pocket;
  • The aforementioned Mindfulness Bell;
  • Certain rituals at various times of the day to which I adhere: yoga and meditation upon awakening, a Friday, 10 a.m. call to a close friend to tell each other about our respective practices, a daily writing of a Mindfulness Nugget to send to a listserve of current and former students and friends;
  • Various essential personal communities, from my monthly men's group to my weekly practice group;
  • Certain aspects of my work itself, including preparation for and leadership of the two mindfulness groups that Rezvan and I lead each week.
With this constellation of practices and habits, I'm seldom far from a reminder that calls me home. The more I take this on, the more infused my day is with a sense of peace and of being at home, comfortable in my skin, in communities of people through which I move, and in my world.

So, while I'm no longer neurotically driven to achieve some notion of ceaseless practice (as I was as a beginner practitioner), I'm enjoying the gradual transformation of my life that is resulting from a daily commitment to call myself, over and over again, back to Self, back to Now, back to Here.

Sunday, January 3, 2010

Karma

A friend of mine just wrote me with an inquiry about karma. She read something about it and her curiosity was piqued, sensing that she might be able to make some positive changes in her life if she just understood this better.

Here is what I wrote:

Dear M. . .

Well, at its heart, karma is the law of cause and effect. Every cause has an effect that ripples endlessly throughout time and space. The consequence of this cuts two ways. First, each of your actions has an infinite number of effects. Being mindful of this basic law is perhaps the most important thing one can do about it. With mindfulness comes an enhanced capacity to choose clearly among courses of action. So, the study of mindfulness is an excellent place to start with this aspect of karma. This is what we teach at NIH, and, while our source material comes from a broad array of authors, the most important is likely Jon Kabat-Zinn. Among his books, I recommend Full Catastrophe Living, Wherever You Go There You Are, and Coming to Our Senses: Healing Ourselves and the World Through Mindfulness. He also has a mindfulness cd you can download, Mindfulness for Beginners

Let me be clear: reading the books won't do it. This is not something to study like economics or history. This is something to study like a violin--by doing it. So, the purpose of the books is to teach you how to do the exercises, and not so much to give you understanding so that you can be smarter about this.

The second consequence of karma is that your current situation is the product of an infinite number of causes. By definition, these have all happened in the past and are therefore out of your control. This is not fatalism--this is fact. All that is--right now--is beyond your present control. While you may have some influence over the next moment, based on what you do in this moment, the context in which you take that next action is a given: it's already been provided. Some of your present situation has been provided by you and your decisions; some of your present situation has provided by others and their decisions. Because all of these causes are in the past, they are, in this moment, out of your control.

Therefore, a very important learning from the law of karma is bound up in acceptance. Tara Brach, a teacher from around this area, has written a book called Radical Acceptance. she also has a CD of guided meditations. The practice of radical acceptance of all that is is not easy, yet it is essential, for as long as we fight against that over which we have no control, we will suffer.

The Serenity Prayer has been very helpful for me in the last few months, as I believe I have told you. It is particularly powerful when practiced in the context of Radical Acceptance. When faced with a sense of powerlessness, and the associated anger and/or frustration, my practice has been to return to the question, "what can I do?" There is much I cannot do, and if I focus on that, I will remain locked in a prison of my own making. There is, however, much I can do, in this moment, once I have fully accepted all that has led up to this moment.

Again, the key is practice, not understanding. Daily, repetitive, diligent practice. There is a story: a boy became interested in history, so he read all of the books he could get his hands on and became a historian. He then became interested in economics, read all the books he could get his hands on, and became an economist. He then became interested in swimming, read all the books he could get his hands on, and drowned.

I leave you with a prayer by Dag Hammarskjöld: For all that has been ... Thanks. For all that will be ... Yes!

This is a blend of radical acceptance and an openness to what's next.

Love,

Tom

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

Hierarchical Love Maps

My young friend Blair Haggett posted a Facebook inquiry into levels of love, making a valiant effort to organize various types of love into a hierarchical system. Daring to go where few dare to tread, he does an excellent job, including pointing out the limitations and problems with his own system.

Is hierarchy bad? Hell no! Some things are higher (or deeper) than other, love included. Then what's the problem?

Here's how I replied to Blair, and I'm thankful for his thought-provoking catalyst for this riff:

==============

I think one problem is that we have too many meanings for this one word. Because of that, purely tiered systems cannot hold up and contain all the meanings.

Now, if we pick a narrower meaning for love, stick to it, we might be able to tier that meaning, and then, say, come up with another word (e.g., "wahoo"?) for another dimension of love, and then tier that. Example: What if "love" simply describes our circle of compassion? If we limited it to that, then ever-widening circles would constitute our "tiers of love." So, my love for my mom and dad (only) would be subordinate to my love for mom, dad, and sibs, which would be subordinate to the love that included uncles and cousins, and so on until we talk about a much broader (higher?) love for all sentient beings, then love for all beings sentient or insentient, etc.

Then, if we use, say, "wahoo" for that flavor of what we might call love that also involves lust or passion, then we could probably tier that. For example, "I wahoo you if" (you stay good-looking, you're rich, you are well thought of, smart, evolved) is subordinate in our Tiered Wahoo System to "wahoo because" (you're good-looking, rich, smart, evolved, etc.), which is then subordinate to "wahoo in spite of" (all your flaws).

The Greeks did a better job than we by having at least a couple of major words for what we now lump to gether under the love umbrella, but I think the Family of Love has a lot more children than two.

So, let's draw more than one or two hierarchical "love maps"!

===============

Thanks again, Blair. That was fun!

Serenity Prayer, Redux: Rain is Wet: Get Over It

Serenity prayer, first part:

God grant me the serenity
to accept the things I cannot change;
courage to change the things I can;
and wisdom to know the difference.

Oddly enough, this is the core of my recent practice, the one that has pulled me out of my summer doldrums. I say "oddly enough" because it is an overused-to-the-point-of-trite aphorism and as old as the hills.

Yet, in its core, it is radical.

First, Radical Acceptance. What would it be like to accept everything that is unchangeable? Or, even more radical, to embrace it? To embrace it all. To even love it all. I daresay few of us have succeeded in taking this first line of the prayer to its maximum interpretation.

Rephrased:

I choose to love all that is.

And now, the rest of this first part, Radical Responsibility.

To ask, what choices do I have, what can I do now? Not some Secret-inspired narcissistic responsibility for all of creation, but a clear-eyed assessment of what I can do. Very often we obscure this view so as to evade responsibility for our actions and lay it elsewhere. We have far more choices than we typically admit.

A classic trick -- we deny the choices we are making where the consequences of choosing otherwise seem dire. For example, "I cannot quit my job." The truth is, unless you are enslaved, you can always quit your job. Now, the consequences may be serious, but you can always quit your job. "I'm stuck in a terrible relationship." Nobody is stuck in a terrible relationship that they cannot choose out of. We can tell an endless string of these lies to ourselves and others, painting ourselves into a corner of perceived helplessness and victimization.

What is the practice?

Use moments of anger, despair, frustration, as warning signals, and then consciously ask questions like:
  • What can I do, right now?
  • What power do I have?
  • Where in my life do I have the capacity to influence?
Build a day out of these questions.

What about the rest of the problems, the ones beyond my control?

I have used humor to great effect. For example, when I catch myself whining about some idiotic pundit, or the foolishness or even evil of some people, or the brevity of life, I try to come up with a similar complaint about a thing I cannot change, like "rain is so wet! God I hate that rain is wet."

Of course, I could choose to move to the desert . . .

Monday, August 24, 2009

The flaws in our wood

I've been grappling with lingering, general dissatisfaction. While many things and people have, from time to time in recent weeks, been the object of that dissatisfaction, meditation reveals that the core dissatisfaction has been with certain aspects of my self that some inner voices have described as "flaws". Of course, this is not the first, nor will it be the last, time I engage in this kind of self-criticism. This particular bout has been resilient to my normal approaches.

Driving back from South Carolina yesterday, I put on David Whyte's recitation of his poem, The Faces at Braga. Suffice to say, the tears came when he reached the lines:

If only we knew
as the carver knew, how the flaws
in the wood led his searching chisel to the very core,

we would smile, too
and not need faces immobilized
by fear and the weight of things undone.

By the way, I recommend you get "Close to Home", the 1992 CD that has his recitation set to gorgeous music.

Here it is in its entirety. Thank you, David.

The Faces at Braga

In monastery darkness
by the light of one flashlight
the old shrine room waits in silence

While above the door
we see the terrible figure,
fierce eyes demanding, "Will you step through?"

And the old monk leads us,
bent back nudging blackness
prayer beads in the hand that beckons.

We light the butter lamps
and bow, eyes blinking in the
pungent smoke, look up without a word,

see faces in meditation,
a hundred faces carved above,
eye lines wrinkled in the hand held light.

Such love in solid wood!
Taken from the hillsides and carved in silence
they have the vibrant stillness of those who made them.

Engulfed by the past
they have been neglected, but through
smoke and darkness they are like the flowers

we have seen growing
through the dust of eroded slopes,
then slowly opening faces turned toward the mountain.

Carved in devotion
their eyes have softened through age
and their mouths curve through delight of the carvers hand.

If only our own faces
would allow the invisible carver's hand
to bring the deep grain of love to the surface.

If only we knew
as the carver knew, how the flaws
in the wood led his searching chisel to the very core,

we would smile, too
and not need faces immobilized
by fear and the weight of things undone.

When we fight with our failing
we ignore the entrance to the shrine itself
and wrestle with the guardian, fierce figure on the side of good.

And as we fight
our eyes are hooded with grief
and our mouths are dry with pain.

If only we could give ourselves
to the blows of the carver's hands,
the lines in our faces would be the trace lines of rivers

feeding the sea
where voices meet, praising the features
of the mountain and the cloud and the sky.

Our faces would fall away
until we, growing younger toward death
every day, would gather all our flaws in celebration

to merge with them perfectly,
impossibly, wedded to our essence,
full of silence from the carver's hands.


David Whyte, Where Many Rivers Meet

Sunday, May 31, 2009

Hope: All it's cracked up to be?

hope
–noun
1. the feeling that what is wanted can be had or that events will turn out for the best

Nearly two decades ago, I heard a trainer in a personal effectiveness training I attended say "hope is overrated."  

I found this surprising -- St. Paul spoke very highly of it, placing it up there with faith and nearly up there with love.  So what was the problem?

I think this trainer's problem with it is that it tended to relieve a person of responsibility, the kind of responsibility that might induce the person hoping to take action in order to  have what one wanted.   To him it vested the Powerful Other (whoever that might be for a particular person) with too much power and the individual with too little.  In his mind, "I sure hope that happen" was inferior to "I will make that happen."

That made sense to me, and my early-30s self stopped giving much thought to hope.  But now, I'm believe there may be another problem with hope, a more serious one: its rootedness in the future.

This becomes quite apparent if one is practicing radical acceptance of what is.  Hope almost always presumes that what is now is not as desirable as what might be later.  To the hoper, the grass is always greener on the other side of the achievement of what is hoped for.  

Jerry Jud recently spoke of the radical step he took, after giving over his ego and his name to God, by giving over his preferences, too.  

"Thy will, not mine, be done."

What happens to hope when preferences are turned over to The One, to What Is?  

For most of us, I suspect, it is a bit of an unraveling, an existential threat to the hegemony of the ego.  

"No preferences?  You must be kidding?"

Jerry wasn't kidding, and neither am I.  

No preferences.  Therefore, no hope.

So, now, I'm trying to use hope not as a desired state, but a cautionary alarm.  When I hear myself say (or think) "I hope" with serious intent, I can notice it and ask myself, "am I fully in the present, radically accepting what is, or am I leaning toward the future, toward an alternate fantasy?  Am I clinging to my preferences, or holding them lightly?"

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Bringing the Energy of Satisfaction to Each Happening -- The Practice


A couple of days ago, I heard the founder of Shalom Mountain, Jerry Jud, say this:  "after my morning disciplines move me into a state of Satisfaction, for the rest of the day, my objective is to bring that energy of satisfaction to each happening, as it is happening, no matter what the happening is."  

I've heard some version of this a zillion times over the last three decades.  "It's not what happens to you, it's the attitude you bring to it," is another variation on this theme that I've heard a lot.

But there was something about hearing it from this 90-year-old sage who actually pratices this, lives this, that drove the point home.   Hearing this come from the lips of someone who obviously knows from the inside what it is to do this, every day, helped the point to land in my marrow.

So, what is my version of this?

Certainly, Jerry's approach of doing 90-minutes of disciplines each morning with the expressed purpose of clearing and connecting all his major energy centers is inviting.  But even short of that, I have been playing simply with breathe-attend-smile.   When it occurs to me throughout the day, as often as I can have it occur to me, I take a breath, gather my attention on what is happening in that moment, and issue a smile of satisfaction, regardless of what is happening.  

Breathe -- attend -- smile.

This evokes a version of that "energy of satisfaction" in my bodymind of which Jerry spoke.  Jerry's mantra, "I'm satisfied, Lord!" doesn't hurt, either!

Then, I imagine that this energy is associated with me, here, now, a kind of cloak or aura I carry with me into the next event, and the next, and the next.  In essence, I make my satisfaction-energy portable, and commit to bringing it with me, as I might commit to bringing a precious belonging with me on a trip.

The practice, in this form, is new to me, so I'm still stumbling.  So far, though, it seems quite promising.